Have you ever thought about how power is being transferred within complex PCBs? Yes, it is a challenging job for PCB designers to design a power supply that delivers the required power to each PCB component (ICs, transmitters, capacitors, etc.) since the power requirement for each of these components varies. Only a perfect power supply design can help overcome this challenge.
With the increase in circuit design density and complexity, the complexity of power supply design has also magnified. PCB designers are offered several possibilities for the PCB power supply design and layouts. Despite the varieties in the PCB power supply designs, designers must follow certain rules and deal with common problems concerning it.
Some of the common issues to be handled in power supply design are, EMI, trace design to handle high currents, reducing current loops, selection of components, and following the datasheets’ layout recommendations.
In this article, we will cover the following topics:
- PCB power supply design
- Design consideration for PCB power supply
- Choosing the right regulator for PCB power supply
- Thermal management for power supply
- Ground and power planes for better PCB power supply
- Decoupling capacitor and bypass capacitor
- EMI filtering
- Frequency response for power delivery system
- Power integrity (PI)
PCB power supply design
The purpose of the power supply design is not just converting the power from AC to DC. The function of the power supply is to deliver the power to the circuit components at the correct voltage and current. It will be common to have voltages as low as 1.8V and 1.2V devices in the future. Low voltages bring low tolerance to power supply noises.
Power supplies also require current limits to limit the maximum current. Thus, the important parameters for a power supply are voltage, max current, voltage ripple, and heat loss at maximum current.
The typical power flow of an electronic circuit for power supply is shown in the above figure. Electronic circuits need voltages from 1.8V to 12V range. 1.2V, 1.8V, 3.3V, 5V, and 12V are the most common voltages used.
At the first stage, input AC voltage at 230VAC/110VAC is converted to an isolated DC voltage in the range of 6-12V. A buck-switching regulator is employed at the second stage which converts the 6-12V to 5V or 3.3V. Further, the 3.3V is converted to 1.8V or 1.2V using LDOs (Low Dropout regulators).
Before the advent of Switched-Mode Power Supplies (SMPS – switching power supplies) iron core transformers were used to convert high voltages 230VAC/110VAC to 12VAC. This was further rectified by diode bridge rectifiers to DC volts approximately 12 x 1.4 = 16.8 VDC maximum. Linear regulators were used in reducing the voltages to the required levels. The disadvantage of such circuits was poor power efficiency (less than 80%), high heat loss, larger PCB footprint, and poor power ripple. The use of switching power supplies has improved efficiencies of conversion of voltages to lower levels, reduced PCB footprint of power supplies (very small and light in size), and reduction in ripple.
In linear regulators, a larger amount of power was previously lost due to higher drop out voltages. For example, consider the linear voltage regulator LM7805. LM7805 (5V) typically has a drop out voltage of approximately 7.5V, requiring a minimum of approximately 2.5V difference between input and output voltage. Therefore for a 1A regulator, the power loss in the regulator at 7.5V input will be 2.5V x 1A = 2.5W. With the low dropout regulator LM1117-5.0, the drop out voltage is 6.2V requiring an input voltage of Vout +1.2V at the input. For critical applications, a combination of switching regulators and LDO is used to increase efficiency. For example, from stage one if 7.5 volts is available this will be dropped to 3.3V with a buck converter and then dropped to 1.8V using a linear regulator LM1117-1.8.
Design consideration for PCB power supply
The importance of a well laid out PCB can not be overstated when it comes to designing power supplies. Also, the designer must understand the importance of the power supply operation to make the effort a success.
For the power supply design, the designer needs to execute a good PCB layout and plan an efficient power distribution network. Also, the designer needs to ensure that noisy digital circuit power supplies are separated from critical analog circuit power supplies and circuits. Some of the important things to be considered are discussed below:
1. Choosing the right regulator for PCB power supply
Generally, designers have two options in choosing power supply regulators, linear regulators and switched-mode regulators. The linear regulators provide low noise output but it has higher heat dissipation which requires cooling systems. The switched-mode regulators are highly efficient over a broad current range but the switching noise causes spikes in response.
A linear-mode requires an input voltage higher than the required output voltage because there will be a minimum dropout in voltage. Linear regulators will have considerable power loss and heat dissipation which makes linear regulators less efficient. If you are considering a linear regulator for your PCB design then you must consider a regulator with low voltage dropout and the thermal analysis must be done before going to fabrication. Besides that, linear-mode regulators are simple, cheap, and provide exceptionally noiseless voltage outputs.
The switching regulators convert one voltage to another by temporarily storing energy in inductors and then releasing that energy at a different voltage at different switching times. In such power supplies, fast switching MOSFETs are used. The output from these highly efficient regulators could be adjusted by altering the duty cycle of the Pulse Width Modulation (PWM). The efficiency depends on the heat dissipation of the circuit, which is low in this case.
The PWM switching of switching regulators causes noise or ripple in the output. Switching currents can cause noise crosstalk in other signals. Thus switching power supplies need to be isolated from critical signals.
Switched-mode regulators use MOSFET technology, thus it is obvious that these regulators emit EMI (Electromagnetic Interference) noise. We cannot eliminate EMI from any circuit completely but we can minimize it by EMI reducing measures like filtering, reducing current loops, ground planes, and shielding. Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) measures should be considered before incorporating switched-mode regulators in your design.
When it comes to choosing a voltage regulator, linear and switching regulated power supply are the two obvious choices. Linear controlled power supply is cheaper, but inefficient and dissipates more heat. Meanwhile, the switching regulated power supply is more expensive and requires the connection of more passive components bt it doesn’t easily heat up.
2. Thermal management for power supply
The performance of a power supply directly depends on the heat dissipation. Most electronic components emit heat whenever current passes through it. The amount of heat emitted depends on the component’s power level, characteristics, and impedance. As mentioned earlier, choosing a suitable regulator can reduce heat dissipation in a circuit. The switched regulators are highly efficient since they dissipate less heat.
Electronic circuits operate more effectively at lower temperatures. To ensure devices work in ambient temperature, designers should consider proper cooling methods.
If the designer’s choice is a linear regulator, a heat sink or other cooling methods are recommended if the system allows it. Fans can be incorporated in the design to ensure forced cooling if heat dissipation is high from a device.
Heat dissipation throughout the PCB may not be even. Components with high power ratings may dissipate a considerable amount of heat which creates a hotspot around it. Thermal vias can be used near these components to quickly transport heat away from the region.
A combination of heat-dissipating techniques and cooling methods can create a highly efficient power supply design. Designers can use either conduction cooling methods such as the heatsink, heat pipes, thermal vias, or convection cooling methods like cooling fans, thermoelectric coolers, etc.
3. Ground and power planes for better PCB power supply
Ground planes and power planes are low impedance paths for power transmission. A power supply needs separate ground planes to distribute power, reduce EMI, minimize crosstalk and to reduce voltage drops. The power planes are dedicated to transmitting power to the required areas of the PCB.
The PCB designers need to treat sections of the ground network separately. In a multilayer PCB, one or more layers can be dedicated specifically to ground and power planes. Also, they can reduce interference and crosstalk by placing ground planes between two active signal layers, thereby effectively surrounding the signal traces with the ground.
4. Decoupling capacitor and bypass capacitor
When power is distributed to the components across the board, different active components will cause ground bounce and ringing in a power rail. This could lead to voltage drops near the power pins of components. Under these circumstances, designers use decoupling and bypass capacitors near the power pins of components to provide for short spikes in the current requirement of the device.
The concept behind decoupling is to reduce impedance between power and ground. The decoupling capacitors act as a secondary power source, providing the current needed by the IC. And act as a local source of charge to support a switching event.
The bypass capacitors bypass the noise and reduce fluctuation in the power bus. They are placed closer to the devices or ICs and linked between power and ground to compensate for changes in the power and ground plane potential when many ICs switch simultaneously.
The bypass capacitors are used to suppress inter-system or intra-system noise within an electrical network. All decoupling capacitors have to connect close to the power pins of IC and the other end directly to a low impedance ground plane. Short traces to the decoupling capacitors and ground vias are required to minimize additional inductance in series for this connection.
There are several aspects to consider when selecting a local bypass capacitor. These factors include selecting the correct capacitor value, dielectric material, geometry and capacitor location relative to the IC. The typical value of the decoupling capacitors is 0.1μF ceramic.
5. EMI filtering
EMI radiation can happen from any power lead entering or leaving the enclosure of a power supply. The PCB designers expect the power supply to keep its EMI levels below the frequency spectrum limit defined by them. Therefore, EMI filters are used at power input points to reduce conducted noise.
An EMI filter’s architecture allows it to block the high-frequency noise. It is critical that the designer carefully lays out the filter circuit components to prevent the components from transferring energy into the traces that connect them
6. Frequency response for power delivery system
When power supplies are loaded suddenly, say from no load to full load the voltage output will tend to dip briefly and return to normal voltage. In some cases, the output will oscillate for some time before the voltage settles to normal. If the oscillations are beyond the design limits it will be necessary to tune the output capacitors and compensation capacitors. For example, for LM7805 it’s recommended to put a 0.1μF capacitor next to the output pin. Similarly, sudden unloading of the regulator could cause overshoot and oscillations.
For a better response from circuit design, make sure that the components selected are within design constraints. Whether the circuits are in AC or DC, they have a different response. AC and DC circuits should be considered separately.
7. Power integrity (PI)
Designers should ensure the power integrity of the power supply design. Power integrity is simply the quality of power delivered to the circuit. It is the measurement of how effectively the power is transferred from the source to the load within a system, which makes sure all the circuits and devices are supplied with the appropriate power so that the desired performance of the circuit is achieved.
A power supply with less noise can ensure higher power integrity. Design for power integrity is nothing but managing the power supply noise. There are simulation tools that help to estimate the power quality in a circuit. Such tools help estimate voltage drops, recommend placement of decoupling capacitors, and also so identify hotspots of high current flow in the circuits.
Also read about circuit simulation in our article How Does Circuit Simulation Work?
Good power supplies are the key to the accurate functioning of an electronic device. As we have seen, the PCB designer has several options available when considering the design of a power supply. The choice of regulators, capacitors, and EMI filtering is important in those considerations. Similarly, the thermal effect and load response should also be considered while designing a power supply system.
At the same time, follow the recommendations mentioned in the power supply IC datasheets. The trace thickness and component placement play a critical role in the power supply design.
High-Speed PCB Design Guide8 Chapters - 115 Pages - 150 Minute Read
- Explanations of signal integrity issues
- Understanding transmission lines and controlled impedance
- Selection process of high-speed PCB materials
- High-speed layout guidelines